Sunday, October 02, 2005

Nats MVP & Cy Young

With the end of the season, I'm interested to see what you guys think (even you non-commenters!)

If you were awarding a Cy Young and an MVP just for the Nats, who would you vote for?

I've got a few ideas kicking around in my head, but I'll save them for later.

In the meantime, please leave a comment listing your top 3 MVP votes (in order, please!) and your Cy Young pick. I'll come up with some sort of scoring method and see what you guys decide. If you have a special case for a particular player, comment away!

18 Comments:

  • MVP
    1 Chad Cordero
    2 Nick Johnson
    3 Jose Guillen

    Cy Young
    Chad Cordero

    By Anonymous lurking natsfan, at 10/02/2005 11:29 PM  

  • Give em Both to the Chief.

    By Blogger John IV, at 10/03/2005 12:22 AM  

  • MVP

    1 Brian Schneider
    2 John Patterson
    3 Chad Cordero

    Cy Young
    John Patterson

    I'd like to get some more hitters in there, but I've got too much reason to not vote for the guys: Guillen's inability with RISP, Johnson and Church being injured when we needed them most, Wilkerson's inconsistency. Vinny obviously doesn't get much credit for his three months in the wilderness, Vidro missed half the season and we don't even need to discuss Guzman.

    So it's Schneider and pitchers.

    By Blogger Yuda, at 10/03/2005 12:32 AM  

  • 1. Patterson
    2. Cordero
    3. Ayala

    By Anonymous Other lurker, at 10/03/2005 1:07 AM  

  • Win Shares, in case anyone cares, have it:
    1. Wilkerson
    2. Johnson
    3. Guillen
    4. Schneider
    5. Patterson
    6. Cordero

    VORP is weird:
    1. Patterson
    2. Loaiza
    3. Johnson
    4. Livan
    5. Carrasco
    6. Guillen

    By Blogger Ryan, at 10/03/2005 1:16 AM  

  • MVP
    Chad Cordero
    Jamey Carroll
    (the only everyday hustling SOB that worked when others couldn't/wouldn't)


    Cy Young
    John Patterson

    By Anonymous NationalsNation Blog, at 10/03/2005 5:11 AM  

  • MVP
    1. Brian Schneider
    2. John Patterson
    3. Chad Cordero

    Cy Young
    John Patterson

    By Blogger Brian, at 10/03/2005 7:38 AM  

  • MVP:

    1. Schneider
    2. Carroll
    3. C. Cordero

    Cy Young:

    Patterson

    By Anonymous ghostofwadelefler, at 10/03/2005 8:21 AM  

  • MVP
    1. Chad Cordero
    2. Luis Ayala
    3. Brian Schneider

    Cy Young
    John Patterson

    I feel the need to qualify these. Cordero gets MVP because he saved so many games. If you recall we didn't have a known closer at the beginning of the year and that was just one reason why people thought the Nats would get destroyed. 23 year old Cordero came out of nowhere and led the MLB in saves. Awesome. Is anyone else concerned about his ability to play 162 games though? He went from savior to liability at the end of the year.

    Patterson gets Cy Young because he's hands down the team's best pitcher. His record doesn't reflect his dominance this year, due to crappy run support. The 3.5 man rotation in September also hurt him.

    By Blogger Brandon Kriner, at 10/03/2005 9:35 AM  

  • MVP
    1. Brian Schneider
    2. Nick Johnson
    3. Chad Cordero

    Cy Young
    John Patterson

    By Blogger Mike Sager, at 10/03/2005 9:55 AM  

  • MVP: Johnson

    CYA: Patterson

    By Blogger Basil, at 10/03/2005 10:43 AM  

  • What bjk said

    MVP
    1 Chad Cordero
    2 Nick Johnson
    3 Rick Short (It's my ballot I can do as I want)

    Cy Young
    Patterson (though you could make a very strong case for Esteban Loaiza)

    By Blogger El Gran Color Naranja, at 10/03/2005 10:49 AM  

  • MVP
    1. Carroll
    2. Cordero
    3. Johnson

    Carro1l gets my MVP vote because he did the most with the least - including the least support from his manager. Robinson validated this vote by keeping Carroll on the bench and that petulant LVP Guzman on the field - Carroll was too valuable to put out there.

    Wilkerson and Wilson get mentioned as most valuable strike-out artists.

    Cy Young
    1. Cordero
    2. Ayala
    3. Carrasco

    Cordero edges Ayala even though both of them were the most consisten pitchers on the team.

    By Anonymous A wary fan, at 10/03/2005 11:02 AM  

  • Cy Young:
    1. Patterson
    2. Cordero
    3. Livan

    It's tempting to give it to Cordero. But despite his gaudy numbers, I've rarely felt like he's a lights-out guy like Billy Wagner. More like Jose Mesa--usually gets the job done, but flirts with disaster too much. Patterson is looking like a true #1 starter, this year's W-L record notwithstanding.

    MVP:
    1. Johnson
    2. Guillen
    3. Schneider

    Yeah, he got hurt and faded down the stretch. But back in June when we were winning all those games, Nick was usually the one driving in the go-ahead run.

    By Blogger Carl, at 10/03/2005 11:46 AM  

  • MVP: Barry Srvluga

    By Blogger WFY, at 10/03/2005 12:09 PM  

  • MVP
    1. Livan Hernandez
    2. Chad Cordero
    3. John Patterson

    Cy Young
    Chad Cordero

    On a team that won with pitching and defense (and sometimes pitching in spite of defense) no hitter deserves the MVP. Livan pitched 200+ innings on one leg and usually gave our overworked bullpen the night off.

    By Blogger Nate, at 10/03/2005 4:14 PM  

  • votes from the uk judges

    mvp
    1. wilkerson
    2. patterson
    3. guillen

    cy
    patterson

    hernandez just outside the top 3. cordero lower - closer is an overrated role. schneider's just outside too. johnson would have figured but for injuries.

    for all the baggage, guillen still makes the top three.

    difficult to push patterson to no.1 just cause i have this thing about pitchers and mvp awards. at times he pitched brilliantly, shame his teammates couldn't hit for him.

    wilko was mr consistency (or was he - there seems to be a difference of opinion in previous comments).

    By Blogger pete, at 10/04/2005 4:19 AM  

  • anti-mvp

    10. inning-endy.

    9. ryan howard.

    8. mike scocsia.

    7. andruw.

    6. billy wagner.

    5. havana pete. still screwing the nats from the warehouse.

    4. guzman. need i say more.

    3. f-rob. "wake me up before I go-go"

    2. bowden. for services to other teams - ohka, sunny kim etc.

    1. emperor bud. for jerking the club and the fans forever more.

    By Blogger pete, at 10/04/2005 4:27 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home